0:00
/
0:00
Transcript

Tape Study: Goto vs Callum - Wrestling is Chess; Not a Flipbook

How Storytelling, Psychology, and Timing Still Define Great Wrestling

Squared Circle Podcast is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


🎭 The Match That Wanted to Matter

From the start, the energy was promising. Callum Newman, dubbed the “Prince of Pace,” was stepping into one of the biggest matches of his career. Goto? A warhorse. A veteran who doesn’t just work a match—he commands it. Goto brings presence, pacing, poise. And all of that should have made for a beautiful contrast.

But contrast only works when both elements hold their weight.

Callum came in with one speed—fast. One mode—flashy. And one plan—do what he always does.

Problem is, Goto already knew that plan. And so did we.


💥 When Psychology Breaks, So Does the Match

Let’s talk about the neck. Because it was the story beat—until it wasn’t.

Goto delivers a reverse neck breaker off the top rope. Callum clutches his neck. And for a brief moment, I thought, good. We’ve got our anchor. We’ve got our story.

Then came the flips. The dives. The full-speed rebounds. The Tope Con Hilo.

If your neck is toast, you're not running like it's a track meet. You’re not hitting springboards with clean landings. You're adapting.

Except Callum didn’t adapt. He defaulted. And that broke the illusion.


🧠 Wrestling Is Chess—But This Was Checkers

Goto was playing chess. Calculated. Grounded. Picking his moments. Every elbow. Every knee. Every slam was methodical.

Callum was flipping pages in a coloring book.

Wrestling isn’t just about moves—it’s about the meaning behind them.

If you're selling a neck injury, your offense has to change. Maybe you drop into technical mode. Work a leg. Create space. Drag the crowd into your pain. But if you ignore the pain every time the crowd gets warm, they stop believing. And once they stop believing, they stop caring.

Callum had all the adrenaline. But none of the internal logic.


🗣️ The Commentary Can’t Save You

Even commentary felt like it was walking on eggshells—like they wanted to sell Callum’s heart, his drive, his guts. But you can’t put over a story that isn't being told in the ring.

They tried to babyface him up. Talked about his evolution. His moment. But the performance didn’t match the narrative. It was disconnected. And the fans felt that.

You don’t need a monologue. You need momentum that makes sense.


🔁 Repetition Isn’t Storytelling—It’s Noise

How many times can you go for the same move with the same setup before the crowd checks out? The Oz Cutter is a cool move. But when it becomes your only answer? It’s not a finisher. It’s a question mark.

If you're going to spam it, at least build to it. Tease it. Fake it. Pull it away. Let the crowd crave it. That’s why the RKO works. That’s why the Rainmaker works. They earn the reaction.

Callum didn’t. He hit fast-forward and hoped for a pop.


📉 Goto Deserved a Better Dance Partner

Let’s not forget who this match was really about. Goto is the reigning IWGP World Heavyweight Champion. A man with an encyclopedic understanding of wrestling rhythm. And here he was, stuck in a match where the beats kept skipping.

You could feel him trying to carry it. Trying to slow it down. Trying to give Callum a moment to breathe and recalibrate. But instead, he got a flurry of half-believable hope spots and oversold reversals.

The problem wasn’t that Goto didn’t show up. The problem was Callum didn’t evolve.


🧩 The Missing Ingredient: Coaching

This match wasn’t a disaster—it was a warning. Callum Newman has potential. He’s got fire. But fire without guidance? It burns out fast.

He needs someone to sit him down and say, “Here’s how you make people feel something.” Someone like O’Shea Edwards. Someone who understands that a wrestling match isn’t a stunt show. It’s a symphony.

Wrestling is the only art form where the audience cheers for the author in real time. So why give them a story with missing pages?


🎯 Final Thoughts: Adapt or Fade

I’m not here to bury Callum. I’m here to say that this match wasn’t it. And that’s okay—if he learns from it.

  • Learn how to pace.

  • Learn how to sell.

  • Learn how to shift styles mid-match when the story demands it.

  • Learn how to let your opponent’s strengths guide the tempo.

  • Learn when not to flip.

Because if Akira Francesco can come in raw and become one of the most beloved junior heavyweights by leaning into story, so can Callum.

But you can’t get there on speed alone.

Leave a comment


📣 Coming up: Goto vs Zack Sabre Jr. at Resurgence, then Shingo at Dominion.

And someone remind New Japan that David Finley won the 2025 New Japan Cup. He’s earned his shot too.