In this episode of the Square Circle Podcast, I take a detailed dive into the New Japan Cup event from March 12, 2025. With my characteristic passion and no-holds-barred analysis, I break down the two matches: Taichi vs. Gabe Kidd and Shota Umino vs. Great Okan.
Gabe Kidd’s Dilemma: Passion vs. Paydays
Let’s talk about Gabe Kidd. I’ve got to say, while I’ve always appreciated his gritty, no-nonsense style reminiscent of Stone Cold Steve Austin, his sudden appearances on AEW after losing to Kenny Omega left me questioning his narrative. For someone who passionately denounced AEW, turning around and accepting a payday there felt like a complete contradiction. I get it—money talks. But when you present yourself as someone standing by their convictions, those choices can water down your character.
And it’s not just about Kidd. AEW has this frustrating habit of relying on predictable tropes like matches emerging from interrupted interviews. It’s lazy storytelling, and it’s part of why Kidd’s character lost some of its edge when he went down that route.
Shota Umino's Transformation: A Tale of Identity
Then there’s Shota Umino. When he walked out in that striking all-white outfit with a freshly shaved head, I knew something was up. This visual shift was screaming "new chapter," and I’m all for it. But here’s my issue: his real battle isn’t just in the ring; it’s with his lingering connection to Jon Moxley.
I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again—Shota should’ve gone to AEW to confront Moxley after beating Claudio Castagnoli. Instead of continuing with the New Japan Cup, a showdown with Moxley would’ve been the perfect move to break free from his mentor’s shadow. Shota’s got the talent, no doubt. But to truly step into his own, he’s got to let go of that Moxley attachment.
Booking Critique and Narrative Consequences
Now, let’s talk booking. The count-out win for Taichi felt like a cheap way to progress the story. Sure, it kept both competitors strong, but it robbed the match of a decisive, satisfying conclusion. And don’t get me started on Shota’s new finisher, "Second Chapter.” A delayed fisherman suplex? That move needs to hit harder if it’s going to live up to its name. If you’re calling something the Second Chapter, make it memorable.
I’ll always advocate for stories that resonate. Every match should have emotional stakes, not just moves for the sake of moves. Let the audience feel something. Wrestlers work too hard to have their stories fall flat because of weak finishes and overused formulas.
Final Thoughts
At the end of the day, I love pro wrestling. That’s why I get so passionate when I see decisions that could be better. From Kidd’s complicated narrative to Shota’s journey of self-discovery, there’s so much potential for deeper storytelling. And that’s what I’ll always push for on the Square Circle Podcast.
Want to share your thoughts? Head over to https://marieshadows.substack.com or find me on Fourth Wall. If you’re a wrestler looking for feedback, check out the Tape Study Roadmap. Let’s keep the conversation going!
Share this post